If you find yourself in Paraparaumu Beach, New Zealand, make sure to immerse yourself in the culinary charm of The Surfer's Mistress. Nestled at 10 Seaview Road, this Italian eatery captures the essence of authentic Italian cuisine while enveloping you in a warm and inviting atmosphere. With a phone call away at +64 4 298 7873, your next delightful dining experience is just around the corner.
What sets The Surfer's Mistress apart? It’s not only the menu that shines, but the vibrant energy created by its attentive staff and the surrounding ambience. Diners have raved about their experiences, with Caroline Matheson praising the restaurant's superior service compared to other establishments in the area. Her antipasto platter, abundant and bursting with flavor, along with the salmon and spinach fettuccine, showcases the chef's commitment to crafting dishes from high-quality, authentic ingredients. The use of traditional recipes ensures that each bite feels like a trip straight to Italy.
Another patron, Conrad Johnston, declared it the best Italian restaurant in the region, remarking on the perfectly crafted dishes that strike a balance with delicate flavors. From the lively and contemporary atmosphere to the expert table service, the restaurant promises not just a meal but an experience robust with Italian hospitality.
Special mentions must be made of the exquisite arancini, celebrated by Ferry Hendrikx, and the pasta, which is noted for its freshness and vibrant taste. Couples and families can enjoy a range of options, including delightful pizzas and a commendable tiramisu that Michael Murphy insists is among the best he's had. It's this consistent quality, paired with thoughtfully curated music played at a perfect volume, that invites diners to relax and savor their meals without feeling rushed.
Compliment your meal with a selection from their diverse drinks menu, featuring everything from Peroni beers to refreshing San Pellegrino beverages. And don’t forget the digestivi, the perfect way to conclude your culinary journey.
In essence, The Surfer's Mistress is more than just an Italian restaurant; it’s a celebration of flavorful dishes, genuine hospitality, and a comfortable dining experience that encourages you to stay a little longer. If you're in the area, this spot should be at the top of your must-visit list. Come for the food, stay for the ambiance, and leave with memories worth savoring. Grazie, e stata una bella serata!
Your opinion matters! Help other visitors discover this spot. Your email will stay private. Fields with * are required.
Lärchenbergweg 2, 02681 Schirgiswalde-Kirschau, Germany
Zac du Terminal, Centre Commercial Cité Europe, 1001 Bd du Kent, Channel Tunnel, 62231 Coquelles, France
1122 Naradhiwas Rajanagarindra Rd, Thung Maha Mek, Sathon, Bangkok 10120, Thailand
Kaliurang St, Candi Karang, Sardonoharjo, Ngaglik, Sleman Regency, Special Region of Yogyakarta 55518, Indonesia
Caroline Matheson (Caro)
10/10/2025
Wow it was great better service than we got last week at Logan Brown. The guys are fab and the food was authentic and delicious.Excellent meal thoroughly enjoyed every mouthful. Authentic Italian food. Far better atmosphere than the competition. I had the antipasto platter which was plenty for four and really tasty. Salmon and spinach fettuccine was fab and our guests had a steak and the NY meatballs. Definitely worth a return trip.
Conrad Johnston
21/09/2025
Easily the best Italian restaurant in the region. Every dish we had was perfectly crafted with delicate flavours. The atmosphere was light and contemporary. Table service was excellent.
Ferry Hendrikx
30/08/2025
A classy little Italian restaurant in the middle of Kapiti. Lovely authentic dishes, with friendly, personable service. The Arancini entrees were superb, the pasta fresh and vibrant, and the steak dish just right. The panacotta was also great. It's not the fastest service, but in return, you get freshly made dishes. We'd certainly recommend the Surfers Mistress.
Michael Murphy
24/08/2025
We’ve been here quite a few times now and have always had a really enjoyable meal, great service and seriously one of the best Tiramisu’s. I really appreciate how the music is quiet and tasteful so people don’t have to raise their voices and despite being the last ones there tonight didn’t feel rushed to finish our meal. Seriously thanks so much team for making especially tonight a great experience.
Lili VanZ
04/08/2025
Our waiter was so lovely and friendly. He was helpful and assisted when I asked for suggestions. My caprese salad was just what I needed. My friends had the pizza which they said was delicious. Pistachio ice cream got a big thumbs up too. Grazie, e stata una bella serata
Korrie Gammer
05/07/2025
Back for more! We first visited in April 2022, and were so thrilled to be able to come back today - we were not disappointed! In fact, it might have even been than I remember. The Ragu is divine and dessert a must (we got the panna cotta this time). We live in Wellington and will definitely go out if our way to be back soon ;)
Elin King
27/06/2025
The food was delicious but the portions were very small - I've never seen such a miniscule caprese salad anywhere in Italy! And the arancino, which was as good as the best I've had in Italy, was the size of a large plum rather than an orange. The website needs updating as several of the items advertised were no longer on the menu.